Below are three FOF finalists from last week’s makeover contest. One will win a makeover with stylist Sherrie Mathieson, author of the brilliant makeover book Steal This Style.
(Vote for the finalist that YOU think should win by commenting below. The finalist with the most comments by Wednesday, May 19, 2010 at 5 p.m. (E.S.T.) wins.) Thank you for entering. This contest is now closed.
Francesca Kranzberg, Washington D.C.
Why she thinks she should win: “Because I just lost almost 50 pounds! Although I still have another 80 to go, it’s been so long since I have seen even a semblance of a shape that I simply do not know what to do! And while my daughters are far too kind to tell me I need help, my in-laws aren’t!”
—
Kathleen Silloway, Mohegan Lake, NY
Why she thinks she should win: “Because then my kids can’t criticize me for looking like a schlump!”
—
Cathy Wilson, Tuscon, AZ
Why she thinks she should win: “My daughter is a fashionista with a great sense of style. I share her love of clothes, fashion and shopping, but I just don’t have that knack of putting together a smashing outfit. Both my daughter and my son think I’m attractive and look young for my age, and they get frustrated with me when I dress like MY mother! I’m single, living in a new city, looking for a new job – in essence, starting over again – and I want to learn how to dress fabulously for my age and my figure.”
—
0 Responses to “{Makeovers} The Makeover Finalists Have Arrived!”
Debbie Kaplan says:
I think Francesca Kranzberg would be the prefect person for the make over.Look at that great smile. There is a woman who loves life.
susan says:
Kathleen Silloway-she looks great-and happy! Lots of confidence
Romelia says:
cra_211 (Cristian) / Solo qreuia decir que a la pagina esta muy buena pero le falta RSSGracias Por el capitulos estaba esperando su version
blotijuifa says:
LhytwZ jylrtpfulnlg
vganvnlqsr says:
RVoI9q lkhlocfkibxm
DW says:
Kathleen definitely deserves it. What she didn’t say is that she is actively dieting and exercising. She just needs the makeover to finish the process.
Regina Baker says:
I think Kathleen should win because she is secure in herself. But her kids need to see that she’s more than a schlump!”
Julie Willis says:
Cathy has my vote!
Maureen McGrath says:
Francesca – A just reward for her (VERY) hard work, and an inspiration to keep it going.
Dimples says:
Good Luck! Kathleen Silloway 🙂
Nash says:
Lets Go Kathleen Silloway!!!!
Reda says:
Kathleen Silloway has my vote!
cat says:
Voting for Francesca…. go girl!
Ruth Kellner says:
I think Francesca is a great candidate for a makeover
and a new look to to acknowledge her accomplishment of the weight loss and encourage her to continue!
Vicki Harvey says:
You go girl. Loosing that much weioght you deserve to be pampered and a new fabulous look!
Pat Loehfelm says:
Kathleen – No more schlump – you’ll look marvelous, darling!!!
RL says:
I vote for Francesca. 50 pounds shows a determination that should be rewarded.
Kathy Edler says:
Francesca Kranzberg should win!
Erica says:
Kathleen Silloway!
Nina says:
Kathleen is fabulous and deserves this- came through a tough year with flying colors!!
Daryl says:
I vote for Kathleen – so her kids can can stop saying she looks like a schlump….let’s see her transformed from schlump to star!
Caty says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg – not only is she beautiful on the outside she is beautiful on the inside too! She is a very kind and compassionate person who absolutely deserves to pamper herself and feel like a million bucks – Go Francie!
Joyce Cole says:
Francesca Kranzberg gets my vote. 50 lbs! WOW!
She is so deserving – such a kind and wonderful person.
Jenn says:
My vote goes to Kathleen! It’s her time to shine.
Susan Parker says:
I vote for Francesca. Weight loss of 50 pounds – a makeover will be a great reward.
SL says:
I vote for Francesca. Way to go – 50 pounds. A makeover will be a good reward.
Francie Kranzberg says:
My vote is definitely for Francie – but hoping everyone gets some kind of fabulous makeover!
Dina from Takoma Park says:
Francesca !!!!!!
Francie is an amazing person. She’s really wonderful to the community in DC. To know her, is to be inspired by her! Give her a make-over and let more people know her.
Betty Adler says:
Great! Francie Kranzberg will enjoy it and will always carry her new “aura” wherever she goes! She’s done a great job getting started….help her finish it!
DL says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg!
davida doner says:
Francesca Kranzberg! you go girl…
she gets the makeover as a congrats for the first 50
pat gurevitch says:
I think Francesca would benefit the most from a makeover as she has proven her commitment by losing 50 lbs.
Jim Leech says:
I vote for KATHLEEN. I’m lucky enough to know her and she is soooooooo wonderful. Caring, kind, loving, empathetic, energenic, strong, community minded, and talented are only the first words that describe her. Love her!!!!!!
Beri Kravitz says:
My vote goes to Francie. Way to go!
Karen Havstad says:
Francesca Kranzberg! Awesome keep it going! You definitely deserve a makeover to discover the new you and keep yourself motivated in your weight loss. Good luck!
Fawn Chapel says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg, a strong compassionate woman. How exciting and encouraging it would be for her to have this makeover!
Valerie Doner says:
Francesca Kranzberg is very deserving of the makeover. I have known her for a long time and she is a very hard-worker and a devoted wife and mother. Keep up the good work, Francie! Good luck winning the makeover!
Bill says:
Kathleen has my vote!
Emily E says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg, a very wonderful woman.
Kira says:
I vote for Francesca!
Terri Zall says:
Francesca should win! She has been working so hard and is an amazing person.
Gail Mason says:
I vote for Francie Kranzberg! Congrats on your weight loss accomplishment and goal!
Judy White says:
My vote is for Francesca. She’s great inside and out. She contributes a tremendous amount to her community.
Jan says:
Francesca – Because she seems highly motivated for change.
Kathy Leech says:
Kathleen – she’s a beautiful, strong lady who deserves a treat like this!
Bonnie says:
My vote goes to Francesca she’s a generous person who works hard and she deserves it.
Khalia Jones says:
Kathleen Silloway gets my vote.
Karen says:
Kathleen S. has my vote.
Lisa says:
My vote is for Kathleen. You go girl!
Ursalin Murray says:
Kathleen is a person you can share just about anything with and she will always have a friendly, motherly comment.
Dana says:
Kathleen Silloway gets my vote. This year is Kathleen’s year with many new “firsts”. What an incredible opportunity, well deserved, as she continues her amazing journey!!
Marge Ghilarducci says:
Kathleen Silloway. I don’t know any of these ladies, but I think giving Kathleen a makeover would be a striking difference that I would really love to see.
Jennifer says:
My vote goes to Kathleen! It is very difficult to keep up to date with fashion as a business professional and as a mother. The best reward is to give Kathleen a makeover. Add fashion to her perfect smile.
Barbara Reese says:
I vote for Kathy Silloway. She would be perfect!
Lisa says:
My vote is for Kathleen! You go girl!
Joel says:
Kathleen. Oo la la!
Donna says:
Kathleen has my vote – I bet she’ll look stunning!
Debbie says:
Kathleen Silloway is no slacker (or a schlump)… give her a makeover and she’s sure to maintain “the look”!
Kathy DeMaio says:
I’ve known Kathleen for about 15 years and can’t think of anyone more deserving of this makeover. She has had more than her share of heartache and this would be a fabulous gift for her!! She would look much younger than her years, I am sure!
Janine says:
My vote is for Kathleen! She is a devoted mom who deserves a little pampering!
Monae says:
Kathleen Silloway ALL THE WAY!!!
Marily says:
Kathleen has my vote! A vibrant women with so much to offer.
Allison says:
My vote goes to Kathleen! She’s a wonderful woman embarking on an exciting phase of her life and she definitely deserves a great, new look to go with it!
Tia says:
Kathleen has my vote! Team Kathleen!!!
Dan Conroy says:
No question, Kathleen Silloway’s got this locked up: a great smile, personality to match, brains to spare and a refreshing sense of humor.
Anita Kranzberg says:
I wish they all could win a makeover! But, my vote is for Francesca Kranzberg! 50 pounds is a huge accomplishment! (How many sizes is that?) A make-over could be just what she needs to keep going and get the next 80 pounds off!
Karen Jackson says:
I’d love to see how Kathleen Silloway looks with a new makeover, so my vote is for her! Go Kathleen!
Suzie says:
I vote for Cathy. Just look at her (no offense) she’s got a good thing going but definitely needs help!
blueeyedmorgans says:
CATHY CATHY CATHY!
My vote is for her. She’s definitely in need of a new look to go along with her new life!!
Margaret says:
I vote for Kathleen. I know people think the two others – who are very deserving – have earned it because they lost a lot of weight. But so did Kathleen! She worked very hard to lose weight and keep it off, and everyone knows that’s even harder than losing. Kathleen also had the courage to get out of a toxic relationship and is building a new life. She deserves the makeover for sure.
Kalee says:
My vote is for Kathleen Silloway!
Lisa Smith says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg! She truly deserves it.
minnie says:
One always wishes to be the winner but in reality we know there is always just one. All three ladies are lovely in their own right. Cathy is courageous to be in a new city and starting over. Her daughter sounds like knows what’s in and what’s out. The daughter needs to step up and offer her mom a makeover. Kathleen has the prettiest smile and has something most of us want. She’s slim. Her kids need to stop the name calling and hurting her feelings. They should cough up the makeover gift certificate. Finally Franscesca, she’s earned the makeover. It would be a great motivation for her to continue on her weight loss journey. I wish all 3 the best of luck and the happiest of times. The children of all 3 should be proud, loving, grateful, respectful, and appreciative of their mothers. I wish I could tell them to love their mothers now because one day they’ll be gone. I’d give or do anything to still have my mom to spoil.
Teresa says:
I vote for Kathleen. No one should have to listen to their kids tell them they look like a schlump. Even though I’m sure they mean that in the nicest way!
Margie says:
Francesca – you go girl! You’ve got my vote, and good luck with the next 80.
JBaskin says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg, but it would be great if all of them could get the makeover!
Rebecca says:
Kathleen! She too has lost a lot of weight and has maintained it for years.
jenni says:
congrats on the first 50lbs.. you can make it to your goal weight!
Sharon Doner-Feldman says:
I vote for Francie Kranzberg – she is a beautiful person inside and she has been working so hard to make herself a beautiful person outside. I know how hard it must be to lose so much weight and she deserves a fantastic makeover. Can’t wait to see what you can do for her!
Martha Edwards says:
Kathy Silloway! She’s fun, she’s mature, she’s a classy lady with brains and talent and a killer smile. She got her weight to a lovely, healthy level and, hey, that hair style is perfect!
Helenmhf says:
Francesca Kranzberg…way to lose 50 lbs. very hard to do …please give her the reward!
Donna Ruppert says:
Kathleen Silloway gets my vote. Always in style! And you should hear her speak!
norma says:
A new start is something every 50-something woman needs and deserves! But my vote is for CathyW.
Caitlin says:
Cathy Wilson all the way! She deserves it!
kaiponohea says:
Kathleen gets my vote! Gorgeous, vibrant, fun-loving, and absolutely fabulous!
Katarina says:
I love Kathleen’s smile! She has my vote.
Aisling says:
I’d love to vote for all three, but I’m going to go with Cathy because I can really appreciate her “starting over” situation.
Marcos says:
Kathleen, Kathleen Kathleen! She deserves to be de-schlumpified.
Gwen Dixie says:
Kathleen Silloway deserves this honor right now.’
Francesca Krantzberg is most impressive, but I think she will be even more ready for a makeover when she has lost a few more pounds.
Peg says:
Kathleen Silloway deserves to win the FOF Makeover! She has also lost a lot of weight after battling with it for years – and she’s kept it off which is even harder! She is starting a new phase of her life now with freedom to reinvent her look and reach her full potential.
michelle says:
kathy needs an updated look with her hair and makeup. not that she looks bad, just needs to fast forward her looks alittle.
Jeanette says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg, because I know how it feels when you lose weight and you need a little something else. A makeover would be just great.
tamara says:
My vote goes for Kathleen, what a beautiful smile!
rjcard says:
I vote for Francesca . Congratulations on the loss and keep up the good work
Kathy says:
I am voting for Cathy Wilson.
idrive4 says:
I vote for Francesca, it is amazing that she has lost 50 pounds! Wow!
JoAnn Josemans says:
I vote for Francesca — it takes a lot of determination to lose weight and 50lbs is no small task. kudos to you! Keep up the good work and don’t let anyone get you down.
Missy says:
I vote for Francesca. She is doing what I would like to do, lose weight. I don’t even know how to get started and she already lost 50 pounds and is challenging herself to keep going. She had a real reason why she should be the winner–to be healthy and consequently look fabulous.
Stacey Schneider says:
Francesca Kranzberg
Julie Okke says:
I think Kathhleen should win. It would make her children very happy.
G Culver says:
Kathleen Silloway – she is truly an inspiration!!
Anne Saunders says:
I’m known Cathy for a long long time and is really trying hard to better her life in many ways. She’s also a great sister-in-law and so therefore is so deserving of a makover so I am voting for her. Good luck Cath!
Tami says:
I vote for Francesca Kranzberg. She deserves to win after losing so much weight. A new makeover will be a great confidence builder for her.
Makeover vote says:
My vote is for Francesca–a new do goes along with a new shape.
Terry says:
Francesca Kranzberg, gets my vote! Good luck to all 3!
Sandra Leigh says:
Francesca Kranzberg! She is wonderfully beautiful on the inside, and although she looks lovely, it is always nice to improve and look wonderfully beautiful on the outside.
Elaine says:
I’d love to see you get a great makeover Cathy! Good luck
Rita Snipes says:
I vote for Francesca too! She has lost so much weight and is reaching her goal! YOU GO GIRL!! So proud of you!
Susan Hessel says:
I am voting for Francesca Kranzberg. It takes real courage to lose 50 pounds and this makeover will help her with the remaining 80 pounds.
She is an inspiration to women over 50.
Jodi Gradolph says:
Francesca Kranzberg is my vote because she has made such progress in her weight loss and I think she would love to win!
Lost in AZ says:
Francesca — nothing so empowering as losing weight.
Judy Rodenstein says:
Francesca Kranzberg totally deserves the makeover, and not only because she has just lost 50 pounds. Francie gives so much to her community and is always looking out for other people. I hope she gets this chance to treat herself!
Peggy says:
I voted for Francesea Kranzberg because she lost 50 pounds and since I just lost 60 pounds I know how hard it is and a make-over would be nice for her.
Karen says:
Welcome to Tucson Cathy! (Pretty sure that’s what they meant to spell.) Not sure where you came from, but dressing successfully in this climate can be tricky. What better way to kick off a brand new start than a makeover!
Marjip says:
Starting over takes courage & determination! You have my vote Cathy. Time for a new you style.
Cary Olah says:
My vote is for Francesca- anyone that has gone through the struggles of weight loss knows that a real pick me up (like a makeover) will do wonders for her to continue on her path! It will help you to visualize how the new you will look! You go Girl!
Yombe says:
Oops! I meant Kathleen SILLOWAY!
Yombe says:
Kathleen Stiloway has a great figure, cute face, but isn’t playing up her features. She needs a new haircolor, haircut, new glasses (or better yet, contacts,) flattering makeup, a bra that fits her, and new clothing–after which, guaranteed, she will look like a million bucks!
Carol says:
My vote is for Francesca Kranzberg because I know how low her esteem has been and losing the weights is a lot of work. Now is the time for her to shine and boost her morale for the next 80 lbs.
Hanan says:
I would vote for Francesca Kranzberg because i think she began a long journey and she needs some help with it to make it easier for her to finish it. Hope she wins.
robcoop says:
I vote for Kathleen Silloway cause no one should have kids who think their mom looks like a schlump.
Laura Havstad says:
Francesca Kranzberg is my vote for the best. Losing 50 lbs is no mean feat and I would like to know how she did it. She is my vote for sure.
Renee Bauer Soffer says:
My vote is for Francesca Kranzberg. She is at a point in her weight loss where she could use a new sense of direction and style to help her keep looking better and better and encourage her to lose more weight!
Karen says:
I vote for Kathleen! No one deserves to be called a schlump by their kids. Good luck.
Denise says:
Francesca gets my vote. Her photo shows she cares about her appearance by styling her hair, applying makeup and wearing an appropriate outfit for her age and weight. I’m sure during her peak weight she endured years of difficult stares and now it’s time to give her a WOW moment. Congratulations Francesca on your success!
Anne M says:
Because of her honesty and her drive to continue with her quest.
Dyanne says:
Because Kathleen is a beautiful person inside and out! She just got divorced,one son in college and another one about to leave the nest. She is starting a new chapter in her life and should have new look!
Makeover says:
My vote is for Francesca Kranzberg because after losing 50 pounds, it’s time for a new persona. I know because I’ve just lost 21 pounds and think I’ll take myself to one of the NYC department stores for a new makeover. She deserves it and it’s a wonderful incentive to continue on her quest to lose an additional 80 pounds. You go Francesca! You deserve a new you.
RAS says:
Kathleen Silloway is my choice. It is hard to choose, but she reminds me of a friend and I always wanted to give my friend a makeover…. but since I can never, ever mention it, therefore I vote for Kathleen. You go girl.
margarita says:
both cathy and francesca! they deserve it the most
Becky says:
Congrats to all 3. They might all be deserving, but i vote for Kathleen. What a beauty! None of us want our kids calling us “schlump”
Joanne Vicente says:
I wish I could vote for all of them!
skyewentworth@gmail.com says:
CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL THREE!
My vote goes to Cathy Wilson. Single, starting out in a new city and looking for a job. She could use a little help right now.
Helen says:
of course, I think all 3 should get to enjoy this wonderful experience, but my vote is for Cathy from AZ. The “starting over in life” part is what did it…takes a lot of courage when you’re in your 50…she needs all the confidence she can get!
lorib20 says:
Franchesca. While all 3 would love it, she gets my vote.
ssporter says:
Kathleen Silloway should win.
Sonja Turetsky says:
I would like Cathy Wilson to win.
joellensf says:
Francesca deserves a break! I am someone who has also lost a lot of weight and learning to see yourself differently is part of the process. Leaving the other self behind is the toughest part.
Robin W says:
I think Kathleen would benefit the most. The other 2 ladies look like they’ve already got their fashion house in order. (No offense Kathleen, but your kids are right)
MaryAnn says:
Francesca Kranzberg.
It takes a lot of will power to lose all that weight! This would help give her the incentive to lose the rest of it and have her in-laws eat their words!
Jeanne says:
Francesca Kranzberg – she deserves a treat for her weight loss and something to keep her motivated for the next 80 lbs.
Nina Johnson says:
I think Kathy Silloway. A makeover absolutely make her look more youthful. She has a great face.
Beverly Schwartz says:
Francesca Kranzberg has already put tremendous effort into this process. Your awarding her this makeover will enhance a difficult process and inspire her to continue on this positive path to a healthy lifestyle. What better effect would you want to bestow?
Patricia says:
All the ladies should win, but I know they cant. I vote for Kathleen because she is not thinking of herself but her children. She seems to be perky but humble also.
Sharon Griffiths says:
I think that Francesca would be the best candidate as her hair needs to be reshaped, some hi-lite’s added, it looks like she needs clothing with a touch more color near her face. All three women are beautiful but I think Francesca is the best candidate for the make over. Also good luck with the weight loss.
Ellen Epstein says:
I vote for Francesca. I admire her loss of 50 pounds. She looks terrific and I know how hard it is to lose weight. I’d love to see what you can do for her!
Val Orosa says:
I think Kathleen Silloway should win. She is someone who I can relate to.
Donna says:
Francesca will see the beauty in herself before she loses the last of the weight!
Gail Barlow says:
I would like to vote for Frqnchesca k. She has come a long way and her battle isn’t over yet. She deserves a pick me up to keep her motivated to keep going. It is tough enough what she is doing without in-laws pointing it out to her.
Diana says:
Kathleen Silloway because I myself know what it’s like to have your kids think that you’re a schlump, I took it upon myself to do my own make over so I think that she should have the same chance.
Bonnie says:
Francesca Kranzberg gets my vote because I know what it is to lose so much weight, you really need to start all over in the fashion dept.
You know there are only three ladies, your could give them all a makeover………
Andrea Kline says:
The winner should be Francesca Kranzberg
Mara says:
Francesca — definitely — she deserves it after doing something so good for herself!!! You go!!!!
Stacy says:
I vote for Kathleen – and for all of us that have a little trouble with that fine line between “classic” style and schlump !!!!
jane says:
Francesca should win. It would be a great reward and encouragement for her to continue her efforts!
ebalsamo says:
Her heart didn’t lose any weight. It’s still a big heart that takes all of the people she comes in contact with in! Loving, caring and kind are just three little words that describe Francie!
Kathleen Anne says:
Kathleen Silloway has inconsiderate children – her self-esteem must be in the cellar. Show this woman she can be her naturally-attractive self, and show her that the only opinion that matters is her own!
Roxanne Diesel says:
Francesca Kranzberg – Way to go on the weight loss – Keep up the great work! Just lost 55 pounds myself with about 60 more to go so I know how you are feeling! Good Luck!
Barbara says:
Kathleen Silloway because she needs to show her children all she can be.
Patricia says:
All three are great looking FOF ladies, but, I choose Kathleen Silloway because of her great smile.
eileenrosado says:
Kathleen Silloway. I believe she will look the most chic after a makeover
Lnovak says:
Francesca gets my vote. What an accomplishment to lose 50 pounds. Congratulations! You’ve really earned this wonderful reward.
Rose Linck says:
I’m sure they are all deserving but I vote for Kathleen Silloway. The other two look like they already have a little sumpin’ sumpin’ going on in the fashion and make up department. Kathleen (no offense Kathleen) looks like she is in need right now.
Carolyn says:
I think both Francesca and Cathy deserve the makeover. Goodness knows, loosing 50 lbs is a great achievement and she deserves a reward. Cathy needs it to boost her confidence is starting over. It would be a great help to both of them.
Margaret says:
Francesca is such a good person and she has worked so hard to accomplish what she has. Her story inspires others, like me, to get going on my journey to health and a better weight. This award would be a wonderful way to acknowledge her self-discipline and goal.
Bethstakeonlife says:
I vote for Francesca! She deserves a MEDAL for having lost 50 pounds!
Margarida says:
Francesca should win because she deserves a huge incentive for fighting to lose weight. Bravo!
Nadine says:
I vote for Kathleen because she has taken care of herself and just needs updating. That’s worth a reward.
Cathie Carter says:
Cathy Wilson would be a terrific candidate for a makeover. She loves clothes and makeup and is ready for a new start in a new city. She is fun loving and friendly! She has my vote!
Karen S says:
I think Kathleen Silloway should win. She is attractive and has a nice figure. She definitely has potential to be quite a beauty with a wonderful makeover. With her beautiful smile and joy that comes through in her photo. I believe that her makeover would be an incredible transformation and give her some modern day oomph.
bhavani says:
Francesca, she deserves it after losing 50 pounds. This is the perfect reward and will keep her momentum going (and her omentum shrinking for all you Dr. Oz fans) until she reaches her goal.
sue barenholtz says:
Francesca Kranzberg, has done a great job of losing weight – she deserves the makeover.
chilbert says:
Francesca has worked so hard to loose weight she needs to be able to look in the mirror and see a new person, which is what she is. That will help keep her motivated to get the next 50 off.
belindabg says:
Both Francesca and Cathy are great choices, because it’s very tough as a larger woman to find stylish clothes that FIT WELL. Kathleen, although in need of help, has a great figure and with a modest amount of help could already look fabulous. I VOTE FOR BOTH CATHY AND FRANCESCA!!
Annette Riggs says:
Francesca Kranzberg is a lovely lady just as she is!! But, just think what a makeover will do for her self-esteem and her determination to meet her goals. She deserves this.
she's fifty and FABO!!! says:
I hink that Cathy needed that extra confidence that the make ove gives…she certainly had that spark and energy to begi with!
Rachel says:
Kathleen Silloway is a fab lady, and should have a look that shows it!
Marcia says:
I think they should all benefit, but I see the great effort Franchesca is making. She deserves a break and a make-over.
kimacw says:
Francesca Kranzberg
Karen says:
Franchesca- because I admire her sticking to her dieting plan– that is tough to do!
Dorothy says:
Kathleen Silloway becaus she is the oldest. She deserves it.
admin says:
All the finalists would be great candidates for a makeover!