{Tested} Eye Caramba by DairyFace

“Eye Caramba” cream (retail value: $26.99 for two 2.5 oz. cups) made with milk, by indie beauty brand DairyFace, will “moisten and tighten and brighten” the “sensitive area around the eyes,” and is “also beneficial for the whole face,” according to the company.

Is this eye cream the créme de la créme or…“udderly” ridiculous? 10 FOFs put it to the test. Read on for their reviews.

**Quick Take** 6 out of 10 testers would recommend the Eye Caramba cream to other FOFs.

P.S. Want to be guaranteed a product to test? Join the FOF Beauty Club now!

Jerrilynn Atherton – Biloxi, MS

Did you like the aroma of this product?
[I] loved the aroma!

What did the product feel like on your face?
It felt creamy and luxurious!

Did it nourish your skin?
It nourished my skin very well!

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
My face feels smoother and the wrinkles are less defined.

What was your overall experience with this product?
I enjoyed using the product. I had to write myself a note to remember that it was in the fridge!

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Definitely!

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
5.

Maggie W. Rowe – Wheaton, IL

Did you like the aroma of this product?
No. In fact, this was a real turnoff. I realize the manufacturer was probably avoiding artificial ingredients, but the odor of the product was unpleasant.

What did the product feel like on your face?
It felt good, as it had been refrigerated, but the extra step of having to run downstairs to the kitchen, get it, use it and then return it to the fridge was not one I wanted to take every morning.

Did it nourish your skin?
No. In fact when I left it on longer than 5-10 minutes, it made my already dry skin feel tight.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
[There was] no noticeable difference.

What was your overall experience with this product?
I looked forward to trying it, [but] but was very disappointed.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
No.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
1.

Linda Carroll – Miller Place, NY

Did you like the aroma of this product?
I didn’t care for the aroma, although I got used to it the longer I tried it.

What did the product feel like on your face?
It was very light on my skin. It also felt like it was tightening my skin while it was on my face.

Did it nourish your skin?
Not really.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
I was hoping that my face would feel smoother, but I really didn’t see any difference.

What was your overall experience with this product?
It was easy to use, but as I said I didn’t see any difference in my skin.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
No.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
2.

Bonnie Sanchez – Lynnwood, WA

Did you like the aroma of this product?
Yes.

What did the product feel like on your face?
[It felt] very smooth.

Did it nourish your skin?
I thought so.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
Yes.

What was your overall experience with this product?
[It was] very nice, not oily.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Yes.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
4.

Carol Melodia – Newport Beach, CA

Did you like the aroma of this product?
Yes.

What did the product feel like on your face?
It felt like yogurt with olive oil.

Did it nourish your skin?
I believe so.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
Maybe.

What was your overall experience with this product?
It felt good. My dry skin seemed to absorb it within 10 minutes.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Yes. The price seems a bit high but I liked it. I think it would take six months or a year to know if this product was a real winner.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
4.

Patti Stern – Moreland Hills, Ohio

Did you like the aroma of this product?
[It had] a very clean smell. I liked it!

What did the product feel like on your face?
The product felt amazing on my face. [It was] so refreshing, cold and wonderful. [It] was the best part.

Did it nourish your skin?
The product superficially nourished my face. [It did] not absorb into the deeper layer.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
No. It is a short term fix, just like a face mask.

What was your overall experience with this product?
The product felt fantastic when applied–cold and refreshing. But it does not have any redeeming value to me, because it has to be refrigerated and I travel for business every weekend.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
I can’t recommend this item. It is a one shot wonder. [It’s] great when applied, but [it] does not have any [of the] anti-aging qualities that I look for in every product I use.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
3.

Deborah Girard – Quitman, Arkansas

Did you like the aroma of this product?
Yes.

What did the product feel like on your face?
[It felt] soft and refreshed.

Did it nourish your skin?
Yes.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
Yes.

What was your overall experience with this product?
[It] makes my face smooth and soft.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Yes.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
5.

Kate Rivas – Tenafly, NJ

Did you like the aroma of this product?
I enjoyed the aroma as it was not overly scented or sweet smelling. [It was] just a nice light scent.

What did the product feel like on your face?
The product at first felt very rich, [then] tempered down as if it was not even there.

Did it nourish your skin?
It definitely nourished my skin. I could even see the increased hydration.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
My skin was smoother after five or six days. [The] results were great.

What was your overall experience with this product?
[It was an] excellent experience. I enjoyed using it. [It felt] great on my skin and [I had] wonderful results.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Yes. It feels great to put something on fresh from the refrigerator.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
4.

Sandra Barbee – Aliso Viejo, CA

Did you like the aroma of this product?
I thought the aroma was fresh.

What did the product feel like on your face?
[It was] very cooling.

Did it nourish your skin?
Very slightly.

What was your overall experience with this product?
Fair. Regular yogurt works with the same results.
Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
No.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
2.

Jackie Decataldo – Sparta, NJ

Did you like the aroma of this product?
The aroma was very slight. It didn’t bother me at all.

What did the product feel like on your face?
The product felt very cool and refreshing on my face. I enjoyed the coolness of it.

Did it nourish your skin?
Yes, definitely.

Was your face smoother after 14 days?
Yes. My face felt like a babies’ bottom.

What was your overall experience with this product?
I was very pleased. My skin really responded to it.

Would you recommend this product to other FOFs?
Yes.

Please rate this product from 1-5 (with 5 being the best):
5.